Capitalism is inherently a hierarchical system. There are workers, managers, bosses, and owners as one set, and then on a more macro scale, there are the winners and losers across the competitive market. As a company ‘wins’ against another, its market share grows in tandem with its economic power, and it rises up the hierarchy. More powerful companies become more likely to win against weaker companies, so there is a tendency in capitalism toward monopoly – hence the advocacy for government oversight in areas like competition bureaus, consumer protection, and so on. While this tendency isn’t the focus of today’s blog, it’s important to remember that capitalism goes hand in hand with the accumulation and centralization of power in the hands of fewer and fewer people.

Democracy is, at its core, a horizontalist system. ‘One person, one vote’ is a dynamic of equality in decision making about the direction of a country. If someone can’t vote or if someone has more votes than somebody else, the structure collapses and is no longer a democracy. In theory, power in democracy is a flat line.

It’s not that complicated.

These two structures cannot coexist. A hierarchy and a flat line are necessarily incongruent. This is an intrinsic contradiction of capitalism, and there are two mainstream pathways to resolving it inside the goal of trying to make capitalism and democracy compatible. The first pathway is liberalism. Liberalism aims to make things easier for those at the poorer end of the hierarchy, and attempts to address past discriminations to allow for those historically forced to be at the bottom some leeway to maybe get ahead. Contrary to popular belief, policies like a wealth tax or Medicare For All are in fact liberal, not socialist, because their aim is to soften the sharp edges of capitalism rather than address the hierarchy itself. Liberalism does not seek to abolish power imbalances but make capitalism more fair. However, this does mean that those at the top do have to cede some power in order for liberalism to function. This is why liberalism is often seen as anticapitalist because the accumulation of power is intrinsic to its fundamental ideology. Why would you want to punish someone for their success?

The second pathway to address the contradiction of capitalism and democracy is conservatism. Conservatism is the belief that people are naturally a certain way, and therefore will rise or fall into the position on the hierarchy where they belong. The hierarchy is Right. The hierarchy is Good. If you’re poor, that’s because of who you are. If you’re rich, it’s the same story. If you moved your way up the hierarchy, it’s because you pulled yourself up by your bootstraps in accordance with your strength of character and will. Intervention to address the natural categorizing that capitalism produces is arguably immoral because then people end up in roles alien to their character and nature. Arlie Hochschild’s book Strangers in Their Own Land goes deep into conservatism and finds grievance at others’ “cutting the line” with the liberal handouts that they’re receiving – perhaps getting further than the conservative who is participating in capitalism the right way. The unfairness that conservatives see isn’t a hierarchy that privileges some over others, but people not following the rules in order to get ahead.

Don’t ask where the rules come from! In fact, don’t ask questions at all…

The thing is though, conservatism as an answer to capitalism is bullshit in a way that speaks to the core of the conservative movement today. Telling the poor and disenfranchised that they belong in their destitution is a cruelty that both liberals and leftists have been crowing about since the beginning of capitalism. It is not a tenable belief system, particularly as the excesses of capitalism disenfranchise more and more of the population, making the likelihood of this massive amount of people ‘belonging’ in poverty and despair more and more unlikely. Donald Trump disrupted conservatism by calling it out for exactly this. His solution was neither leftist nor liberal but based in the already-established conservative trope of singling out the ‘cheaters’ who are getting ahead by handouts and liberal policies. The calls for a return to a glorious past, the effusiveness for the military, the hyper-fixation on the threat of the other – these tropes of fascism all rise from the failures of conservatism. Fascism is a rejection of the conservative righteousness of the broadly secular hierarchy of capitalism wherein gays, Jews, and immigrants can thrive, and a rejuvenated embrace of all its remaining tenets. Since a hierarchy must be maintained because the democratic alternative is unthinkable to a conservative who still maintains that some humans are better than others, the master race emerges as the remaining solution.

Is the answer then not more liberalism? Can’t America be saved by the wave of new ‘socialists’ calling for Keynesian economics? Isn’t a softer capitalism a viable alternative to the shifting Overton Window toward blossoming fascism in Europe and the Americas? Can’t we just take a fraction of the power from the powerful to humbly offer the powerless and still maintain the system that concentrates power in their hands?

Help us, Bernie-Wan Kenobi! You’re our only hope!

Racism didn’t actually exist until around the turn of the 16th century when Europe began to colonize the rest of the world and build up its slave trade. Europeans needed a way to justify their horrifying treatment of these humans who had darker skin, and thus was born the notion that human beings are classified into a hierarchy of categories. Prior to this, there wasn’t much need for racism. The monarchs and aristocrats had their higher position by the grace of God; this was the foundational story that justified their power over others. The powerful had all the weapons and God on their side. Why tell a story pitting the lower classes against each other when they were all more or less equal in their baseness and had no means of resisting? Under a democracy where the lower classes are allowed a vote, this is obviously a different story.

Racism evolved as a tool to allow the powerful to exploit and oppress other humans and dull the layperson’s empathy that might be revolted otherwise. There was actually considerable humanistic pushback against both colonialism and slavery in the British homeland, recognizing and rejecting the brutality against darker skinned peoples as rightfully inhumane, but also because these were new ways of accumulating wealth that confronted established power. If a Brit can go to India or the Americas and accumulate more wealth than a Brit at home, that is a threat to established conservative power. They were ‘cutting the line,’ as it were. There was a battle of stories that had to be told in order to determine which group of powerful people would win; the colonizers and slavers using racism to justify their wealth, or the conservatives who believed that these vicious hooligans in the colonies were gaining unearned power according to the dearth of their character. Conservatism, even with its contemporary humanism, and as it always will, lost.

Hard to imagine today that this was the result of conservatism losing!

Fast forward to the Great Depression, when the contradictions of capitalism perhaps first became apparent to all. No longer was it obvious that the poor belonged in their positions on the hierarchy, and fast on the heels of the gilded age where wealth had concentrated into the hands of the few, the seeds of fascism took root. In areas of Europe, fascism won. In America, liberalism did. It was not a sure thing, as groups like the openly fascist America First Committee and the presidential campaign of William Dudley Pelley belied a simmering fascism in the American psyche (notwithstanding the Nazis incorporating American Jim Crow laws, an American staple, into the bedrock of their political enterprise). However, New Deal economics was the success of liberalism against the threat of fascism, and America’s golden age dawned, but because capitalism persisted, it could never maintain its success for long.

Liberalism thrived in the post-war period. America had a booming middle class, a university education and housing were cheap, and good union jobs meant that a single income could sustain a family. Of course, racism still existed. Cities would close pools rather than have black people swim in them when desegregation gained momentum, punishing everyone. The liberal push grew and grew, confronting hierarchies that didn’t even have a name – patriarchy wasn’t understood as the social control of men over women until second-wave feminism adopted the label in the 1960s and 70s. Black people got the vote. More and more people were able to participate in capitalism.

Cinnamon rolls not gender roles!

As liberal as America was being back home, it maintained its capitalistic imperialism abroad. It assassinated the democratically elected leader of Iran in 1953 in order to maintain the stranglehold of oil and gas companies in the region. It deposed the democratically elected leader of Guatemala in 1954 to benefit the banana plantations of the Chiquita corporation. American intervention in international affairs was nothing new, but my point is that American imperialism avoided any of the liberal reformation happening at home, barring the exception of the Vietnam War protest which really only existed as a popular movement against the deaths of American citizens and the nature of the draft.

Hard capitalism did not disappear during this time. It maintained its position abroad through coups and exploitation of foreign workers. If Americans were going to demand a living wage, capitalism would seek labour elsewhere. Globalization developed to allow the free flow of capital in an effort to maximize power and profit. Of course, if labour was able to flow freely, that would dampen capital’s coveted power and profit. If immigrants flooded well-paid America, wages in their home countries would have to rise in order to compete. If capital can jump from country to country, a fair system would demand that labour have the same opportunities, no? The Free Market, indeed. If liberalism was going to be successful alongside capitalism, capitalism needed an outlet. Immigrants and foreigners are just too easy to exploit, and racism would continue to be the cudgel used to justify the worst of capitalism’s excesses abroad, same as it was during colonization and slavery.

Can’t have that!

While I think it would be simplistic to name the Powell Memo as the sole instigator of the conservative backlash to American liberalism at home, it is a useful framing device. Prior to Lewis Powell becoming a member of the American Supreme Court, he wrote a memo to the business-minded U.S. Chamber of Commerce in 1971 essentially identifying liberalism as a threat to the elites, and offered a call to arms to resist it. He advocated for corporate involvement in every avenue of life, from schools to politics, and because the course of history widely shifted in this direction after that, it is often pointed to as the founding document of neoconservatism in America, beginning the trend culminating in MAGA’s Project 2025.

America’s modern turn against liberalism broadly mirrors its colonial and imperial policies by bringing them home against its own people. The same tools used to exploit foreigners and indigenous people were turned against the American middle class, gutting it. The goal was capitalism back home, its violence perfected against foreigners who nobody thought to care about with those same foreigners being blamed when the hardness of capitalism begins to be felt by your average citizen. The hierarchy of capitalism never disappeared, it took a little holiday abroad for a few decades before coming back, rested and ready to get back to work.

This is surprisingly an apt depiction of the modern viceroy of globalized capitalism.

Another reason that everyone hates liberalism today is that it has been coopted by the capitalists for their own machinations. Centrists across the globe, from Mark Carney in Canada, to most Democrats in the United States, to Emmanuel Macron in France, and so on, are exclusively working at the whims of capitalism. Liberalism’s current form is only tangentially connected to softening capitalism’s hierarchy, and it is more associated with doing hard capitalism politely. The ‘socialists’ of today are as well so-called because there’s a needed distinction between their liberalism and the ‘liberalism’ of liberals today. The Overton Window has shifted so far to the right that actual rejections of capitalist hierarchy are not even acknowledged, let alone discussed in the established political forums.

This is all a very long way of saying that liberalism will always fail just as much as conservatism in the face of capitalism because concentrated power will never willingly let go of any of it. They will coopt liberal language with concepts like the Girl Boss and allow gays in the military, but they will never abandon real power. Capitalism has hierarchy baked into its mould, and liberalism will never, ever be able to escape that. The powerful will always come back whenever they’re pushed, harder and smarter than they were before. Because they need an outlet for the impotent rage of today’s serfs and peasants in a way that the previously powerful did not, fascism will always be inevitable so long as capitalism remains king.

Karl Marx once predicted that communism was the natural culmination of history given the contradictions of capitalism and democracy could never sustain themselves. His horizontalist system is indeed an escape from the constant battle between the haves and the have-nots, though the methods of accomplishing this goal are unfortunately murky and tainted by history. Marx, however, was right that capitalism cannot sustain itself. What he did not consider, perhaps as an optimist, was that there is another pathway that capitalism could take, and it is just so easy to hate immigrants.

While defining terms is always ambiguous, as any Socratic analysis of a potential virtue might be, I’m going to look at the concept of “strength” as a binary of two distinct yet related characteristics. On the one hand, strength is the capacity to act; as power. On the other hand, strength is the capacity to endure; as resilience. To wit, the gym maxim of “no pain, no gain” highlights the resilience of strength, and the sculpted muscular physique that results from that endurance represents nicely its power. Strength as pains; strength as gains.

What would Jesus bench?

The symbolism of the weightlifting process and therefore the inextricability of this binary is often used to justify strength as a virtue. Might does not make right but is right. The strong are virtuous because they have suffered in order to gain that strength. Think of the white man confronted with his privilege who defensively brings up all he has struggled. Or Elon Musk, who now denies that his father owned shares in an emerald mine despite admitting as much in an interview in 2014. The illusion of meritocracy demands that those at the top must have earned that position in order for a just universe to exist. Might must be right because the moral foundations of our vastly unequal society would crumble otherwise. The justification for their power has to be their resilience, the binary of strength holding this rotted-out house of cards together.

The virtue of resilience exists even without power. The cancer patient who fights every day to get out of bed to attend chemotherapy in order to make it to Christmas. The recovering drug addict who relives the sober pain of their past traumas and manages to resist the unyielding craving to press the “fuck it” button and live in numbness once more. The unhoused person who manages to get a job, pull themselves up by their bootstraps, and begins to live a shade above desperate poverty. These virtuous souls use what limited power they have to make unearthly choices every day to succeed beyond what anyone might expect of them. While eagle-eyed readers can likely tell where this is all going, I say with all sincerity that the people who manage to do these things are beyond impressive. Their courage, determination, and passion for life are humbling. But is their capacity to suffer virtuous?

If the Fresh Prince can do it, you can too!

A character that I find myself returning to again and again is Bigger Thomas, the protagonist of Richard Wright’s novel Native Son. Bigger is a young black man in 1930s America. He is angry, he is violent, and he is abusive to people he cares about. He ends up killing a nice white woman and, later, his girlfriend through a series of events that elucidate an oppressive social system that plays just a big of a role in these killings as the choices that he makes. Bigger Thomas, regardless of his actions, was always going to be damned.

We understand the viciousness behind Thomas’s choices as existing in a context; it is a mechanism of survival. Bigger Thomas is a kind of resilient that we do not often hear about. Wright’s success with this novel is that we see all of these events as a tragedy, nothing is justified, but we see them with a clarity often hidden. Thomas’s sole motivation throughout the novel is simply to stay alive. His resilience is not a virtue. His resilience is basic necessity.

Read books!

Is the cancer patient who simply goes through the motions of care, living only through momentum, immoral? Is the drug user who continues to use drugs because if they weren’t numb they would kill themselves less of a person than the one who stoically triumphs over their addiction? Is the homeless person who chooses to sleep outside because the housing options available are restrictive, unsafe, and disgusting imbued with a sin no god would ever forgive? All of them are surviving, but they are doing so on their own terms. This is the resilience that we fear.

We have determined that there is a socially acceptable way of dealing with pain – a position that is very easy to hold on the outside of it. Social workers and counselors are a taught strengths-based approach to therapy, and the classic modus operandi of engaging with someone who has experienced a trauma is to reframe their narrative of victimization into one where they are a brave survivor. You’ve been through so much, and look how strong you are for continuing to move forward! You are an action hero who has been hit by a car and is carrying on toward justice with barely a limp!

God, and he’s been shot and/or stabbed too!? Who doesn’t want to be John Wick??

I’ve written previously about the “noble” professions that exist as the bulwark against the sea of desperate inhumanity keeping the people inoculated against the cognitive dissonance that would arise if they ever became aware of how their society creates the conditions that flood its streets with desperate inhumanity. I once worked with a young woman who had been addicted to crystal methamphetamines for years. A baby-step of a month into her sobriety, she tells me she was raped after being offered a ride home from a Narcotics Anonymous meeting. She was violated in a place that was supposed to be the agreed-upon cure to her ailment. She stayed sober despite this, and I pointed out the strength it must have taken to endure such a devastating encounter. Her words to me, spoken between sobs, “I don’t want to have to be strong anymore.”

We demand perfection from our victims in every instance of pain. Palestinians cannot be mourned in their genocide if I can point to one of them and call them antisemitic. Capitalism cannot be condemned if I can point to a welfare bum and call them lazy. The concept of resiliency does not exist solely to justify the mighty but also to dismiss the demands of the powerless. If you simply suffered in a way more befitting of polite society, perhaps you would not be in such a predicament!

I just read the line as British, that’s all. Seems British.

Both instances of strength as a virtue appear more to justify the social status quo than they do to justify a genuine life well-lived, as Aristotle intended in his ethic. This isn’t new. We have to abandon strength as a virtue not just to validate the lived experiences of those who endure pain in ways we might not understand, but also to nullify the justifications of the powerful for their righteousness. If someone tells us that they earned their power because of how much they suffered in their striving toward this goal, we should ignore them because it does not. fucking. matter. While achieving greatness through adversity is certainly an inspiration, so is having massive, quivering biceps, and we do not ascribe an ethical imperative to the latter. The common sense ethical imperative is actually to reduce pain, and while the methodology of that reduction can have reasonable debate, the end goal should not. As a society, we appear to have given up on this goal, preferring instead to find ways to justify accepting the world as it is. Personally, I’ve stopped telling victims of abuse that they’re strong, and instead reinforce that their pain is, in fact, bullshit.

After 9/11, there was a massive uptick in hate crimes against Muslims… and Sikhs, too. It was a tough time to be brown, generally. Racism was on open display, as prominent Muslim voices were routinely asked to condemn Islamic terrorism before being allowed to speak on even irrelevant topics. Terrorism was a burden carried by all Muslims in the West, and that was incredibly racist of all of us to allow this generalization to take place.

After October 7th, there has been a significant increase in antisemitic hate crimes as well. It is a tough time to be Jewish. What I see as different between the two rises of hate crimes is that the link between Islam and Jihad as it was expressed by groups like Al-Qaeda is not widely accepted in the Muslim community. Mosques across the world do not hang the flag of ISIS in prominent locations. Muslim summer camps across North America do not teach kids the importance of aggressive Jihad as a fundamental component of their belief system. There is no broad institutional link between Islam and terrorism; hence, it was racist to make that the underlying ideology of American foreign and domestic policy. Zionism as the belief in the necessity of a specifically Jewish ethno-state has no such exculpatory claim. It is perfectly reasonable to criticize religions like Islam (and Christianity, for that matter) for its treatment of women since there is a textual basis for this, and there is an amazing feminist movement within Islam that is attempting to address that. So too should it be reasonable to criticize Judaism for its widely-held belief in a uniquely Jewish state (and there is a great anti-Zionist movement within Judaism as well).

Put ’em together, and you get the American-Israeli war on Iran!

This is obviously a very complex and fraught comparison, but I think it has merit. It is perhaps unfair to single out Israel as The Jewish State when there are many Islamic States and many of them are behaving badly, notably Sudan with its own genocide in the works, that do not elicit the same response as Israel. If there were multiple Jewish states with diverse sets of policies, it’s easy to see that pinning the acts of Israel on Jewish people generally would hold a greater degree of antisemitism. Iran can claim to be the representative of Shia Islam, but there are other countries with high Shia populations and many in the Shia diaspora that vehemently reject Iran as their religious nexus and this is easily recognizable as valid differentiation.

However, the way that Israel as a homeland functions as part of Jewish belief, there can’t be multiple Jewish states. Israel is the Jewish state, and while Islam has political methodologies embedded into its belief system, these can be interpreted in many different ways across a variety of localized cultural perspectives. There can be only one Israel, and maybe that’s unfair to the Jews, but that’s kind of the point of this article. Whether we like it or not, Israel is the sole state representative of Judaism.

Now with parts of Syria, and parts of Lebanon, and all of Palestine!

The difficulty of combatting the rise of antisemitism is thus how to differentiate Jew from Israel when so much of the Jewish religious institution has support for Israel baked into it. If a Jewish representative is giving an impassioned speech against antisemitism in a synagogue with an Israeli flag hanging on the wall, inconspicuously wafting behind them, how can we take that seriously? If a Jewish summer camp teaches children that Israel brought civilization to an untamed wilderness, and this is the legacy of their people and a formative part of a young person’s identity, how do we then cleave that child from the acts of their homeland? The concept of dual-loyalty is a pernicious form of antisemitism, but it is not helped by a socially-accepted establishment that embraces Israel as part of the Jewish faith. How much antisemitism would there be in Canada right now if the Jewish people and communities across this country rejected Israel as much as our Persian neighbours reject Iran?

I was listening to a “debate” between podcasters Daniel Maté and Jesse Brown, two Jewish men of differing views on the threat to Jews in Canada. Brown’s thesis is that antisemites do not need an excuse to hate Jews and that these people have found their home in the pro-Palestinian movement. If we bring up subjects like a Jewish embrace of Israel as a reason for antisemitism, then we are blaming Jews for their own victimization. To an extent this is true; a random Hasidic man who is assaulted walking down the street is a victim regardless of his beliefs. We can’t lock up Japanese immigrants in internment camps because of the actions of a government they walked away from. However, if there was broad and vocal support for Japan and its actions during World War II among Japanese-American communities, I still wouldn’t suggest locking them all up, but it would make sense that there would be consequences to that.

Was the Nanjing Massacre justified? We’re just asking questions!

To be clear, this does not excuse violence against Jewish people, their places of worship, or their businesses. To understand the reasons behind bad behaviour is not to condone it. I can understand the reasons behind both terrorism and even the Palestinian genocide, so I don’t think it’s taboo to explore why antisemitism is on the rise. But people have a hard time with nuance, so I’ll repeat myself: this stuff is all bad. Beyond the fundamental inhumanity of antisemitism, it is also antithetical to getting the Jewish community to separate itself from Israel since groups that are attacked tend to close ranks rather agree that the position of violence is offering reasonable points.

It is critical we address the rise of antisemitism. I agree with Brown on that point. We cannot have a repeat of Japanese internment camps – not that we’re anywhere close to that in Canada, but the general idea remains. I disagree that the blame lies with the pro-Palestinian movement because this violence does not exist in a vacuum. It would be like blaming the Allies for the negative attitudes toward the Axis. It is right and good to fight against fascism and genocide, today as it was back then. It is also right and good to distinguish the individual from the institutions, even as some individuals may support that institution. We’re all still human.

The one true religion!

I am not Jewish, so I can’t contribute very much to the internal dialogue that needs to happen within that community. Much like the feminist movement within Islam, the voices of outsiders are not worth very much in which direction the current will end up shifting. However, I am Canadian, so I do get a say in the direction of this country. I don’t like seeing a rise in hate crimes, and I don’t see the current siloed approach to addressing it as effective.

In the same way that I don’t think a meaningful conversation about jihadi terrorism can exist without addressing Western intervention in the Middle East, so too I don’t think a meaningful conversation about the rise of antisemitism can exist without addressing the genocide of Palestinians. Saying the terrorists simply “hate our freedoms” is the equivalent of saying that antisemites “don’t need an excuse.” Arguably, the violence against Jews today is a continuation of the terrorism that came to our attention on 9/11 as it is an on-going response to the Western intervention and imperialism in that region. There is a vacuum of accountability in the West manufactured by ignoring and denying our own role in perpetuating violence and repression, and the compounding progression of that global gaslighting campaign has led us to where we are today. Even more than a conversation, action is required on both antisemitism and the genocide and ethnic cleansing in Palestine, and I think they need to happen in tandem so we don’t make the same mistakes we made in the past.

Canada recently joined a baby-step of an international boycott on goods coming out of the illegally occupied West Bank (despite our lengthy history of condemning the Boycott, Divest & Sanction movement because it “demonizes Israel”, but I suppose one day everyone will always have been against this). This could be done in cooperation with the pro-Palestinian movement as well as one or more of the many Jewish groups that are vocal and active in condemning the actions of Israel. It could be done in repudiation of the antisemitism at home, reinforcing the distinction between the Jewish population and the state of Israel. Politics is not separate from communities. The personal is political. I wish we had politicians that could address that bridge, but we do not. I hope that we as citizens can try our best to do so on our own in the interim.