I have a hard time caring about the Trucker (Freedom) Convoy occupying the capital city of my country right now. This could be because I’m on the West Coast, and the noise from all the car horns fades out somewhere over the middle of Alberta, so I’m not directly impacted by the enhanced interrogation being meted out on hapless Ottawans. Unfortunately for me, and for those who only follow this blog out of spite, I’m forced to write about it because despite my best efforts to evade the garbage fire of social media that defends far-right protests, the garbage fire found me. I won’t get into it. Anyway: freedom! That’s never been a toxic buzzword belying oppressive undertones! Let’s get into it!
The garbage fire demands that I ignore all the images and stories of atrocious behaviour because there are nice people in the protest too. Yes, there may have been cheers and people shouting, “Yes! Right here!” when a speaker asked what a white supremacist looked like, but some protesters also cleaned up the Terry Fox statue after it had been previously defaced by the crowd. So like, just because residents of a women’s shelter are being harassed for wearing masks, that doesn’t mean there isn’t some benevolent act of kindness happening elsewhere to cancel it out.
The thing is, the behaviour of protesters has nothing to do with the content of their protest. Does a Nazi in a nice suit having a polite conversation eliminate the violence intrinsic in the belief of callous disregard for the humanity of “lesser races”? No. It’s all public relations. If people looked at the burning of a Target during the Black Lives Matter protests and thought, “Well, I guess I think unarmed black people minding their own business should be killed more now!” then… there’s a protest in Ottawa that might interest you.
This is all very lucky because despite the Canadians demanding States’ Rights by protesting Provincial guidelines in front of the Federal Government, all they want is freedom! It’s the name of the damned convoy, after all! Just a wee bit of freedom! When you started asking freedom to do what, or freedom from what, that’s when it starts getting a little wonky.
In theory, this protest started as a bunch of truckers upset that they would be mandated to receive a vaccine despite being an essential service that didn’t even need to quarantine during the worst of the pre-vaccine pandemic. Honestly? Given the historical amnesty to truckers the government had been providing thus far, an about-face of that magnitude could reasonably be demonstrated against to some degree if only on principle. However, the big trucking alliance of Canada didn’t organize this. They’re against it. The people who organized this convoy have something else on their mind.
Canada Unity, which did organize the rally, proudly posted their Memorandum of Understanding to their website. It has since been taken down because people keep pointing out how problematic a polemic demanding the overthrow of a democratically elected government is, but fortunately links to it still exist. Now, it cannot be overstated how dumb this Memorandum is – I’d recommend giving it a read. Anyone listening to the news has probably heard that they’re calling for the Senate and the Governor General to ally themselves with Canada Unity to overthrow the Liberals and band together to eliminate pandemic restrictions; again, a provincial jurisdiction. That’s not why I’m dedicating a whole paragraph to this thing. They refer to every single piece of human rights legislation in the last hundred years, including the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act, without actually pointing to where any of those human rights are being violated within the strictures of the legislation. It’s like they did a Google search for “human rights” and “medicine” and just copied out everything they could find without reading any of it. They also wrote out, “This Memorandum shall be construed in accordance with the Laws of Canada and the International
Human Rights Commissions” as if wishing could make it so. Ultimately, my reason for writing so much about this Memorandum is this:
Because it’s funny.
Other organizers include Tamara Lich, former secretary for a Western separatist party that wants to abandon the federal state, and Benjamin Dichter who is a smidge racist, but so far hasn’t been overtly demanding the overthrow of the Canadian government. With these players behind the scenes, it kinda seems like the whole convoy is being driven by a far-right desire to abandon democracy and get rid of the government because they just hate the Liberals and Trudeau so much. The pandemic is more of a pretext. This would certainly explain why they went to Ottawa rather than, say, the provincial governments who are, and I can’t stress this enough, actually in control of the mandates and restrictions that impact every day Canadians.
Now, it’s entirely possible that the organizers of a protest are merely the catalyst for a movement that spiraled out of their control, and the vast majority of protesters don’t align with what the convoy organizers had in mind when they sent them all to the nation’s capital. Fine. Let’s say they really do just want to get rid of all vaccine mandates, all restrictions, everything to do with the pandemic and go back to normal. Unfortunately, at its core, what this belief entails is a tacit acceptance with the dying off of the elderly, the immuno-compromised, and the vulnerable. Even if the convoy is only about what its most ardent apologists say it’s about, it still espouses a eugenicist belief that makes sense for white supremacists and Nazis to hop on to. The weak must be purged to allow normalcy for the strong. Pointing to a few ethnic minorities at the protest doesn’t eliminate that fact.
Let’s look at some context. The Americans recently surpassed over 900,000 Covid deaths. Let’s compare that to the number of American deaths from every war they’ve ever been in since the Revolutionary War that started the dang country. Take a moment to think of what that number might be, and then read that it’s 1.35 million. In two years, America has had almost as many deaths as they’ve ever had from war. Add in a new variant after Omicron, and they just might beat it in another year. People have made jokes that the anti-maskers wouldn’t have survived the Blitz on England during WW2 with their whinging about having to wear a piece of fabric over their mouths for a much more destructive catastrophe, but if we’re making war analogies, they wouldn’t be whiny babies, they would be collaborators, traitors to the common good of society by facilitating the spread of the virus.
Masks work. Vaccines work and are safe. The vast majority of people are in favour vaccine mandates, vaccine passports, and restrictions because the vast majority of people understand that masks and vaccines and all of those things are effective in saving lives and keeping the world going. It’s arguable that the Liberals won over the Conservatives in the last election because Justin Trudeau was stronger on vaccine mandates than Erin O’Toole. We have plenty of government mandates that nobody argues about; you can’t smoke in restaurants anymore because people noticed that what smokers exhaled was toxic to those around them when it was contained in an indoor space – sound familiar? And how many in the convoy do you think wore their seatbelts, used their turn signals, and stayed on the right side of the road on their trek to Ottawa? Data doesn’t exist on this, but I can safely imagine it’s all of them. Could be because these mandates keep road users safe, and the truckers didn’t want to die on the way to their protest demanding their right to spread a deadly disease. Golly gee.
When the garbage fire expresses shock at the mainstream media disregarding the “good” happening in the convoy and wish they took the protest’s message more seriously, this is why nobody takes it seriously. What the protest is asking for doesn’t work in protecting people from the virus, isn’t popular, and wouldn’t even return life back to normal, economically-speaking. #BestSummerEver! Unless what is being asked for is actually to overthrow the Canadian government, what is being asked for doesn’t actually make empirical sense. At least a far-right coup is logically consistent.
With all that said, the same article I linked to suggesting that very few people are against Covid restrictions still outlines that mental health levels are reaching critically low points, and government approval is tanking. Nobody is enjoying the pandemic; nobody is enjoying restrictions. Most people just recognize that extreme measures are needed to make sure we don’t kill off all our loved ones. That doesn’t mean that nothing can be done.
If I turned this into a blog about all the things that could be done to ameliorate people’s lives during the pandemic, it would be way too long and I’ve already spent more time than I wanted writing it. Just-In-Time supply lines have proven ineffective, and the general motive to consistently seek out the lowest bidder to develop every aspect of our economy has proven incredibly destructive. The number of hospital beds in 1980 was 6.75 per 1000 inhabitants, and that dropped to 2.5 in 2019 – we have been very much neglecting our health sector. “Flattening the curve” was argued to ensure our healthcare system wouldn’t be overwhelmed, but it was overwhelmed every day before the pandemic even started. There’s lots more that could have been done. Uniform and reliable paid sick leave would have been nice. Maybe a Universal Basic Income so that people wouldn’t be forced into unsafe working conditions? We’ve tried it successfully before…
The idea of protesting pandemic measures, or seeing the nuance in guideline enforcement, is necessary because we haven’t done it perfectly. We can always be smarter in how we handle the pandemic, and democracy demands public accountability. Heck, most provinces have even already cut back a lot of restrictions, though a gradual return makes far more sense than quitting cold turkey. However, Covid-19 has highlighted a significant number of issues in our society that I never even got into: the deadly consequences of insufficient housing and evictions, what counts as essential to society and how well it’s respected, and so on. Unfortunately, the vast majority of us turned to Tiger King to comfort us in our ennui rather than do something about it. The far right decided to do something about it; they’re just myopically focused on their hatred of liberals and Liberals. People who might have more nuanced views about how pandemic measures could have been done better either keep their mouths shut, or join a thinly-veiled fascist and ableist mob. That’s not a binary that’s going to make the world more livable. I mean, doing nothing is clearly the better choice, but it’s choosing the conditions that are allowing the fascistic percolation to maintain itself. Who knows what kind of monster the status quo will birth if we give it enough time.
Blog for Chumps 
You’re fighting a losing battle. You don’t want to be like that out of touch pretty boy with the wide eyed panicked stare in Ottowa. That’s a bad look.
No one believes in facts or evidence any more. Too many lies in circulation. Science is just a word. Bad facts drive out good. Sane people believe what they experience personally, and very little else. All else is presumed to be lies or distortions. Name calling is old and busted. When everyone’s a Nazi, no one is.
The consensus reality is shifting with a vengeance. The Overton window will leave the slow behind. Can’t fight it. Try to get out of the way. If you can’t choose the winning side, then don’t choose a side at all. There’s no law saying you have to choose a side. You can just grab some popcorn and watch the drama. It is TV, after all.
There’s a reason most people don’t talk politics. Many reasons, in fact. Politics isn’t something you talk about. It’s something you do – or watch as a spectator sport.
I find during times like these that reading a lot of history gives me perspective – even though I don’t entirely believe history, but there are patterns. Nothing is permanent. This too will pass. Things run in cycles. Things run in cycles because the people trying to drive events don’t realize they’re running in circles. They don’t understand what “revolution” actually means because they can’t be bothered to consult a dictionary.
Keep your head low. Don’t fly a flag unless you have a dog in the fight. Don’t die on the hill of a hopelessly mixed metaphor.
Gonna address these one at a time:
1. I disagree. Plenty of people believe in facts and evidence. About 80% of Canadians are fully vaccinated, and as I highlight, the vast majority of Canadians are in favour of mandates and restrictions. The issue isn’t facts and science, it’s siloing and disenfranchisement that results in disruptive groups of the ill-informed. Purposeful misdirection for financial or political gain doesn’t help either.
2. People who wave Nazi flags or advocate for eugenics (or both!) can reasonably be called Nazis. I get that it’s often used as a misleading catchall term, but I don’t think that it is being misused in this instance for those reasons.
3. History can be quite illustrative, you’re right. There was plenty of protest against mask mandates and restrictions back in the 1918 flu epidemic too. It’s useful as it shows that this is a common, successful way people have managed pandemics in the past, and like I said, there’s plenty to criticize in the way the Covid pandemic has been handled, just as I’m sure there was plenty to criticize 100 years ago too. I can imagine the protests back then weren’t all that nuanced either, but who can say.
4. I’m not sure what you’re saying with regards to choosing a side. I feel I’m quite obvious in my position (I’m against the convoy). Are you saying that those against the convoy are fighting a losing battle? Or are you saying that those who want to avoid garbage fires are destined to be stuck having to deal with them? I didn’t want to talk about the convoy because their arguments are bad, and it’s no fun arguing against illogical positions (hopefully I have illustrated already why the arguments are illogical above). I try to do this blog for fun, but sometimes I’m forced into it when I have opinions that I can no longer repress.
5. Why would you think I’m advocating a position similar to Justin Trudeau? Some of the failures I highlight are federal jurisdiction (cutting health transfers, for one), and I say that a lot of the feelings toward the protest are legitimate, just misdirected and thus corrupted. I think I spell out pretty clearly that I don’t really care about the protest’s methodology, and honestly they’ve been quite successful in their civil disobedience with relatively little physical violence – it’s just that what they’re advocating for is eugenics (and that’s the good position! The bad one is the overthrow of democracy…). I think that’s quite a different position from most political leaders who let this sit fairly idly until trade with the US was impacted, including Mr. Trudeau who really only put out a few sound bites prior to declaring a national emergency just today.
I take it all back. Keep your head high. Fly your flag proudly. Go on record for the ages. You are you, and will always be you.
And my advice to Trudeau: dig in. Tough it out. Stay the course to the end.
Because if there’s one thing history teaches us, it’s that events have to come to a conclusion sooner or later. Great men are just grist for the mill. As are mediocre men in positions of power. As are the foot soldiers who do the actual fighting. They’re all grist.
I’m not sure free will exists. Maybe we’re all playing pieces of the gods.
I recently blogged: solve for pattern. But that’s not everyone. If you solve for pattern, you rise above the pattern. And if everyone does that, what happens to the pattern?
I became a communist today!
It’s about time!